HE Fighting Game Rating 2004: Unterschied zwischen den Versionen

Aus Hardedge Wiki
Zur Navigation springen Zur Suche springen
Keine Bearbeitungszusammenfassung
(→‎Top: anzeigefix)
 
(41 dazwischenliegende Versionen von einem anderen Benutzer werden nicht angezeigt)
Zeile 1: Zeile 1:
http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/3930-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/
= Orginal Thread =


*1 = CVS2
Initiator des Votings ist Iczer gewesen. Die Idee dahinter war aktuelle Trends im Forum statistisch abzubilden. Den ersten Vote-Thread findet man hier: [http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/3930-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/ Link]
*2 = GGXX#R
*3 = KOF98
*4 = KOF2K2
*5 = KOF2K3
*6 = LB2
*7 = MOTW
*8 = MVC2
*9 = PJ
*10 = RB2
*11 = SC2
*12 = SF3S
*13 = SFA3
*14 = SS0
*15 = SS4
*16 = ST
*17 = SVC
*18 = T4
*19 = TTT
*20 = VF4E
*21 = VS


= Entries =
2004 wurden 21 Titel für den Vote ausgewählt. Die Auswahl bestand aus im Tactics Bereich besprochenen Titeln.
{| cellspacing="1" style="text-align: left; color:black;"
! style="width:50px;" |VoteNr.
! style="width:350px;" |Spieltitel
! style="width:50px;" |Kürzel
|-
|1
|[[Capcom vs Snk 2: Mark of the Millennium 2001]]
|CVS2
|-
|2
|Guilty Gear XX #Reload
|GGXX#R
|-
|3
|The King of Fighters '98
|KOF98
|-
|4
|The King of Fighters 2002
|KOF2K2
|-
|5
|The King of Fighters 2003
|KOF2K3
|-
|6
|The Last Blade
|LB2
|-
|7
|Garou: Mark of the Wolves
|MOTW
|-
|8
|Marvel vs Capcom 2
|MVC2
|-
|9
|Project Justice - Rival Schools 2
|PJ
|-
|10
|Real Bout Fatal Fury 2: The Newcomers
|RB2
|-
|11
|Soul Calibur 2
| SC2
|-
|12
|[[Street Fighter III 3rd Strike: Fight for the Future]]
|SF3S
|-
|13
|Street Fighter Alpha 3
|SFA3
|-
|14
|Samurai Spirits Zero
|SS0
|-
|15
|Samurai Spirits 4
|SS4
|-
|16
|Super Street Fighter 2 Turbo
| ST
|-
|17
|[[SNK vs. Capcom: SVC Chaos]]
| SVC
|-
|18
|Tekken 4
|T4
|-
|19
|Tekken Tag Tournament
|TTT
|-
|20
|Virtua Fighter 4 Evolution
|VF4E
|-
|21
|Vampire Saviour
|VS
|}
= Voting Tabelle =


{| cellspacing="1" style="text-align: center; color:black; border: 1px solid #B5B5B5"
{| cellspacing="1" style="text-align: center; color:black; border: 1px solid #B5B5B5"
! style="width:100px;background-color:#D9D9D9;" |Member
! style="width:50px;background-color:#D9D9D9;" |VoteNr.
! style="width:30px;background-color:#D9D9D9;" |#1
! style="width:30px;background-color:#D9D9D9;" |#1
! style="width:30px;background-color:#D9D9D9;" |#2
! style="width:30px;background-color:#D9D9D9;" |#2
Zeile 47: Zeile 122:
! style="width:30px;background-color:#D9D9D9;" |#20
! style="width:30px;background-color:#D9D9D9;" |#20
! style="width:30px;background-color:#D9D9D9;" |#21
! style="width:30px;background-color:#D9D9D9;" |#21
! style="width:30px;background-color:#D9D9D9;" |N/A
|-
|-
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61335-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61335 Iczer °1]
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61335-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61335 #1]
|8.8
|8.8
|7.6
|7.6
Zeile 59: Zeile 135:
|9.0
|9.0
|7.0
|7.0
| style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" |N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" |N/A
|9.2
|9.2
|9.8
|9.8
Zeile 70: Zeile 146:
|8.8
|8.8
|8.4
|8.4
|1
|-
|-
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61336-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61336 Xeo]
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61336-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61336 #2]
|7.5
|7.5
|9.9
|9.9
Zeile 85: Zeile 162:
|9.6
|9.6
|8.2
|8.2
| style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" |N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" |N/A
| style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" |N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" |N/A
|8.0
|8.0
|2.0
|2.0
Zeile 92: Zeile 169:
|5.0
|5.0
|8.5
|8.5
| style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" |N/A  
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" |N/A  
|3
|-
|-
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61337-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61337 Moskovskaya]
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61337-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61337 #3]
|8.0
|8.0
|9.0
|9.0
Zeile 102: Zeile 180:
|8.0
|8.0
|9.5
|9.5
| style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" |N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" |N/A
| style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" |N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" |N/A
|9.0
|9.0
| style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" |N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" |N/A
|9.5
|9.5
|9.0
|9.0
| style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" |N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" |N/A
|8.0
|8.0
|10.0  
|10.0  
|7.0
|7.0
| style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" |N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" |N/A
| style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" |N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" |N/A
| style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" |N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" |N/A
| style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" |N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" |N/A
|8
|-
|-
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61339-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61339 <nowiki>[STP]Porno</nowiki>]
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61339-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61339 #4]
|7,0
|7.0
|9,2
|9.2
|8,8
|8.8
|9,2
|9.2
|8,0
|8.0
|8,6
|8.6
|9,1
|9.1
| style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" |N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" |N/A
| style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" |N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" |N/A
|9,3
|9.3
| style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" |N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" |N/A
|9,6
|9.6
|8,8
|8.8
| style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" |N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" |N/A
|8,4
|8.4
|8,0
|8.0
|6,5
|6.5
| style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" |N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" |N/A
|7,0
|7.0
|9,8  
|9.8  
| style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" |N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" |N/A
|6
|-
|-
| [http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61340-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61340 <nowiki>[STP]BabaKusA</nowiki>]
| [http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61340-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61340 #5]
| 6.0
|6.0
| 8.0
|8.0
| 8.5
|8.5
| 8.5
|8.5
| 8.0
|8.0
| 8.6
|8.6
| 9.5
|9.5
| 6.0
|6.0
| style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
| 8.7
|8.7
| 7.0
|7.0
| 9.5
|9.5
| 8.0
|8.0
| 5.0
|5.0
| 8.5
|8.5
| 8.0
|8.0
| 5.0
|5.0
| style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
| style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
| 8.0
|8.0
| style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|4
|-
|-
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61342-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61342 The Silencer]
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61342-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61342 #6]
| 8.6
|8.6
| 9.0
|9.0
| 8.5
|8.5
| 9.1
|9.1
| 8.9
|8.9
| 8.7
|8.7
| 9.0
|9.0
| 8.9
|8.9
| style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
| 7.0
|7.0
| 8.5
|8.5
| style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
| 7.6
|7.6
| 7.5
|7.5
| 7.3
|7.3
| style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
| 8.3
|8.3
| style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
| 7.0
|7.0
| 7.5
|7.5
| 8.0  
|8.0  
|4
|-
|-
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61343-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61343 seraph]
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61343-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61343 #7]
|7.5
|7.5
| style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|7.0
|7.0
|6.5
|6.5
Zeile 195: Zeile 277:
|7.9
|7.9
|6.5
|6.5
| style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|8.0
|8.0
|5.2
|5.2
Zeile 207: Zeile 289:
|5.1
|5.1
|9.8
|9.8
| style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|3
|-
|-
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61344-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61344 Adlerklaue]
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61344-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61344 #8]
|5.0
|5.0
|2.0
|2.0
Zeile 230: Zeile 313:
|7.0
|7.0
|4.0
|4.0
| style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|1
|-
|-
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61347-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61347 Akuma]
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61347-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61347 #9]
|9.7
|9.7
|6.1
|6.1
Zeile 254: Zeile 338:
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|11
|-
|-
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61349-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61349 subarashii]
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61349-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61349 #10]
|8.0
|8.0
|9.0
|9.0
Zeile 277: Zeile 362:
|9.0
|9.0
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|6
|-
|-
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61350-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61350 Blastrezz]
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61350-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61350 #11]
|6.0
|6.0
|10.0
|10.0
Zeile 300: Zeile 386:
|10.0
|10.0
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|5
|-
|-
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61351-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61351 CPS3]
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61351-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61351 #12]
|7.0
|7.0
|6.0
|6.0
Zeile 323: Zeile 410:
|2.0
|2.0
|8.0
|8.0
|0
|-
|-
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61353-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61353 Chibi]
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61353-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61353 #13]
|8.0
|8.0
|8.5
|8.5
Zeile 346: Zeile 434:
|9.5
|9.5
|7.5
|7.5
|2
|-
|-
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61355-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61355 Cpt.Atom]
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61355-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61355 #14]
|9.0
|9.0
|9.0  
|9.0  
Zeile 369: Zeile 458:
|7.0
|7.0
|9.0
|9.0
|0
|-
|-
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61359-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61359 <nowiki>[STP]k4oru</nowiki>]
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61359-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61359 #15]
|6.0
|6.0
|9.0
|9.0
Zeile 392: Zeile 482:
|10.0
|10.0
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|10
|-
|-
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61362-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61362 derSteini]
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61362-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61362 #16]
|9.0
|9.0
|7.0
|7.0
Zeile 415: Zeile 506:
|10.0
|10.0
|7.0  
|7.0  
|0
|-
|-
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61364-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61364 SeventySeven]
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61364-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61364 #17]
|9.5
|9.5
|8.7
|8.7
Zeile 438: Zeile 530:
|9.6
|9.6
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|12
|-
|-
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61366-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61366 Venom]
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61366-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61366 #18]
|9.1
|9.1
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
Zeile 461: Zeile 554:
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|8.5  
|8.5  
|7
|-
|-
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61369-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61369 Makoto]
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61369-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61369 #19]
|9.0
|9.0
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
Zeile 484: Zeile 578:
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|12
|-
|-
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61377-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61377 <nowiki>[RD]Grille</nowiki>]
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61377-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61377 #20]
|9.0
|9.0
|7.0
|7.0
Zeile 507: Zeile 602:
|9.0
|9.0
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|11
|-
|-
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61378-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61378 Terry]
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61378-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61378 #21]
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
Zeile 530: Zeile 626:
|10.0
|10.0
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|7
|-
|-
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61385-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61385 Alphaman]
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61385-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61385 #22]
|8.0
|8.0
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
Zeile 553: Zeile 650:
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|7.5  
|7.5  
|10
|-
|-
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61386-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61386 Lomo]
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61386-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61386 #23]
|5.0
|5.0
|7.0
|7.0
Zeile 576: Zeile 674:
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|13
|-
|-
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61387-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61387 Natsu]
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61387-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61387 #24]
|CvS2 : 7.0
|7.0
|GGX2(#R) : 8.6
|8.6
|KoF98 : 8.5
|9.4
|KoF2k2 : 9.4
|8.5
|KoF2k3 : 5.5
|5.5
|LB2 : 8.5
|8.5
|MotW : 10
|10.0
|MvC2 : 2.5
|2.5
|PJ : 7.0
|7.0
|RB2 : 8.4
|8.4
|SC2 : 8.0
|8.0
|SF3S : 10
|10.0
|SFA3 : 6.0
|6.0
|SS0 : 6.0
|6.0
|SS4 : 7.0
|7.0
|ST : 8.0
|8.0
|SvC : 6.0
|6.0
|T4 : 6.0
|6.0
|TTT : 4.0
|4.0
|VF4E : 9.0
|9.0
|VS : -
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|1
|-
|-
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61395-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61395 RBCF]
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61395-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61395 #25]
|CvS2 : 8
|8.0
|GGX2(#R) : -
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|KoF98 : 4
|4.0
|KoF2k2 : 7
|7.0
|KoF2k3 : 5
|5.0
|LB2 : 2
|2.0
|MotW : 6
|6.0
|MvC2 : -
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|PJ : -
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|RB2 : 6
|6.0
|SC2 : -
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|SF3S : 10
|10.0
|SFA3 : -
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|SS0 : 5
|5.0
|SS4 : 3
|3.0
|ST : 10
|10.0
|SvC : 7
|7.0
|T4 : -
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|TTT : -
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|VF4E : -
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|VS :
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|9
|-
|-
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61396-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61396 Rock]
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61396-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61396 #26]
|CvS2 : 1
|1.0
|GGX2(#R) : 7.4
|7.4
|KoF98 : 8.2
|8.2
|KoF2k2 : 8.9
|8.9
|KoF2k3 : 7.9
|7.9
|LB2 : 9
|9.0
|MotW : 10
|10.0
|MvC2 : 5
|5.0
|PJ : 7.3
|7.3
|RB2 : 9.5
|9.5
|SC2 : 7
|7.0
|SF3S :7
|7.0
|SFA3 : 5
|5.0
|SS0 : 5
|5.0
|SS4 : 9
|9.0
|ST : 7.1
|7.1
|SvC : 7.4
|7.4
|T4 : 3
|3.0
|TTT : 2
|2.0
|VF4E : 10
|10.0
|VS : -
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|1
|-
|-
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61398-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61398 Seth]
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61398-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61398 #27]
|CvS2 : 9,5
|9.5
|GGX2(#R) : 7,5
|7.5
|KoF98 : 8,5
|8.5
|KoF2k2 : 4,0
|4.0
|KoF2k3 : 7,5
|7.5
|LB2 : 7,0
|7.0
|MotW : 5,5
|5.5
|MvC2 : 8,0
|8.0
|PJ : 6,0
|6.0
|RB2 : 7,5
|7.5
|SC2 : 8,0
|8.0
|SF3S : 9,0
|9.0
|SFA3 : 9,0
|9.0
|SS0 : 3,0
|3.0
|SS4 : 7,5
|7.5
|ST : 9,0
|9.0
|SvC : 3,0
|3.0
|T4 : 8,0
|8.0
|TTT : 8,0
|8.0
|VF4E : 9,0
|9.0
|VS : 7,5  
|7.5  
|0
|-
|-
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61414-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61414 shind]
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61414-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61414 #28]
|CvS2 : 8.9
|8.9
|GGX2(#R) : 9.9
|9.9
|KoF98 : 6.5
|6.5
|KoF2k2 : 7.0
|7.0
|KoF2k3 : 7.0
|7.0
|LB2 : -
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|MotW : 8.0
|8.0
|MvC2 : 8.9
|8.9
|PJ : -
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|RB2 : 7.5
|7.5
|SC2 : 8.8
|8.8
|SF3S : 9.5
|9.5
|SFA3 : 9.0
|9.0
|SS0 : 8.0
|8.0
|SS4 : 8.0
|8.0
|ST : 7.5
|7.5
|SvC : 5.0
|5.0
|T4 : 7.0
|7.0
|TTT : 8.9
|8.9
|VF4E : 8.5
|8.5
|VS : 6.0  
|6.0
|2
|-
|-
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61433-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61433 creaky]
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61433-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61433 #29]
|CvS2 : 6.5
|6.5
|GGX2(#R) : 8.5
|8.5
|KoF98 : 9.2
|9.2
|KoF2k2 : 8.8
|8.8
|KoF2k3 : 8.5
|8.5
|LB2 : 8.6
|8.6
|MotW : 9.5
|9.5
|MvC2 : 5.5
|5.5
|PJ : -
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|RB2 : 9.3
|9.3
|SC2 : 8.0
|8.0
|SF3S : 9.3
|9.3
|SFA3 : 9.0
|9.0
|SS0 : 6.0
|6.0
|SS4 : 8.6
|8.6
|ST : 8.5
|8.5
|SvC : 7.0
|7.0
|T4 : 5.5
|5.5
|TTT : 5.0
|5.0
|VF4E : 9.8
|9.8
|VS : 8.7
|8.7
|1
|-
|-
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61434-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61434 Grandmaster-C]
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61434-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61434 #30]
|CvS2 : 8.0
|8.0
|GGX2(#R) :
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|KoF98 : 9.0
|9.0
|KoF2k2 : 8.5
|8.5
|KoF2k3 :
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|LB2 :
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|MotW : 8.5
|8.5
|MvC2 :
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|PJ :
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|RB2 : 8.0
|8.0
|SC2 :
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|SF3S : 9.0
|9.0
|SFA3 : 9.0
|9.0
|SS0 :
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|SS4 :
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|ST : 8.0
|8.0
|SvC : 8.0
|8.0
|T4 :
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|TTT :
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|VF4E :
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|VS :  
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|12
|-
|-
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61475-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61475 arit]
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61475-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61475 #31]
|CvS2 : 7
|7.0
|GGX2(#R) : /
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|KoF98 : 4
|4.0
|KoF2k2 : 3
|3.0
|KoF2k3 : 5
|5.0
|LB2 : 6
|6.0
|MotW : 6
|6.0
|MvC2 : 5
|5.0
|PJ : /
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|RB2 : 8
|8.0
|SC2 : 6
|6.0
|SF3S : 9
|9.0
|SFA3 : 8
|8.0
|SS0 : 3
|3.0
|SS4 : 7
|7.0
|ST : 9
|9.0
|SvC : -(n^2) | n -> +-(unl.)
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|T4 : /
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|TTT : /
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|VF4E : 9
|9.0
|VS : /
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|6
|-
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61541-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61541 #32]
|8.6
|6.4
|9.2
|8.5
|9.2
|9.0
|10.0
|8.5
|7.0
|9.5
|8.3
|9.2
|8.7
|8.1
|9.4
|7.1
|8.8
|8.0
|8.4
|10.0
|7.5
|-
|-
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61541-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61541 NeoGeoMeister]
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61548-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61548 #33]
|CvS2 : 8.6
|8.5
|GGX2(#R) : 6.4
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|KoF98 : 9.2
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|KoF2k2 : 8.5
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|KoF2k3 : 9.2
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|LB2 : 9.0
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|MotW : 10
|8.0
|MvC2 : 8.5
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|PJ : 7.0
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|RB2 : 9.5
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|SC2 : 8.3
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|SF3S : 9.2
|9.5
|SFA3 : 8.7
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|SS0 : 8.1
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|SS4 : 9.4
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|ST : 7.1
|8.5
|SvC : 8.8
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|T4 : 8.0
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|TTT : 8.4
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|VF4E : 10
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|VS : 7.5
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|17
|-
|-
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61548-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61548 ukyo]
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61569-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61569 #34]
|CvS2 : 8.5
|10.0
|GGX2(#R) :
|7.5
|KoF98 :
|7.0
|KoF2k2 :
|4.0
|KoF2k3 :
|5.0
|LB2 :
|5.0
|MotW : 8
|4.0
|MvC2 :
|7.5
|PJ :
|5.0
|RB2 :
|8.0
|SC2 :
|6.0
|SF3S : 9.5
|6.0
|SFA3 :
|9.5
|SS0 :
|5.0
|SS4 :
|5.0
|ST : 8.5
|9.0
|SvC :
|3.0
|T4 :
|6.0
|TTT :
|4.0
|VF4E :
|9.5
|VS :
|6.0
|-
|-
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61569-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61569 Tsunami]
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61607-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61607 #35]
|CvS2 : 10
|8.0
|GGX2(#R) : 7,5
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|KoF98 : 7
|9.5
|KoF2k2 : 4
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|KoF2k3 : 5
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|LB2 : 5
|8.5
|MotW :4
|10.0
|MvC2 : 7,5
|6.0
|PJ : 5
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|RB2 :8
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|SC2 : 6
|7.0
|SF3S : 6
|6.0
|SFA3 : 9,5
|7.0
|SS0 : 5
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|SS4 : 5
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|ST : 9
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|SvC : 3
|8.0
|T4 : 6
|8.5
|TTT : 4
|8.0
|VF4E : 9,5
|10.0
|VS : 6
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|9
|-
|-
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61607-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61607 SenseiSD]
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61623-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61623 #36]
|CvS2 : 8
|9.6
|GGX2(#R) :-
|8.0
|KoF98 :9.5
|9.4
|KoF2k2 :-
|7.0
|KoF2k3 :-
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|LB2 :8.5
|9.7
|MotW :10
|7.0
|MvC2 :6
|7.0
|PJ :-
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|RB2 : -
|8.0
|SC2 :7
|8.0
|SF3S :6
|9.9
|SFA3 :7
|9.5
|SS0 :-
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|SS4 :-
|9.0
|ST :-
|9.3
|SvC :8
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|T4 :8.5
|6.0
|TTT :8
|8.0
|VF4E :10
|9.8
|VS :-
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|5
|-
|-
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61623-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61623 goukione]
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61634-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61634 #37]
|CvS2 : 9,6
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|GGX2(#R) :8
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|KoF98 : 9,4
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|KoF2k2 : 7
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|KoF2k3 : -
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|LB2 : 9,7
|7.0
|MotW : 7
|7.0
|MvC2 : 7
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|PJ : -
|7.0
|RB2 : 8
|8.0
|SC2 : 8
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|SF3S : 9,9
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|SFA3 : 9,5
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|SS0 : -
|4.0
|SS4 : 9
|10.0
|ST : 9,3
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|SvC : -
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|T4 : 6
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|TTT : 8
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|VF4E : 9,8
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|VS : -  
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|15
|-
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61659-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61659 #38]
|5.9
|8.4
|9.0
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|7.9
|8.9
|6.5
|7.9
|9.0
|7.5
|9.1
|8.8
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|8.6
|8.2
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|5.8
|9.6
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|6
|-
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61681-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61681 #39]
|8.6
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|7.2
|8.0
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|5.5
|7.3
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|9.3
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|9.5
|8.2
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|8.0
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|7.8  
|11
|-
|[http://forum.hardedge.org/fighting-games/general-fighting-game-discussion/p61730-he-fighting-game-rating-thread/#post61730 #40]
|9.0
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|6.0
|4.0
|5.0
|6.0
|5.0
|6.0
|5.0
|6.0
|8.0
|10.0
|6.0
|8.0
|7.0
|10.0
|2.0
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|style="background-color:#FFC7C7;" | N/A
|5.0
|4.0
|3
|}
|}
= Ergebnisse =
== Rating Tiers ==
*TOP = 8.0 +
*UPPER = 7.5 - 7.99
*MID = 7.0 - 7.49
*LOWER = 6.0 - 6.99
*BOTTOM = 6.0 -
== Top ==
#Street Fighter 3rd Strike (9.04)
#Virtua Fighter 4 Evolution (8.86)
#Street Fighter Alpha 3 (8.21)
#Super Street Fighter 2 Turbo (8.10)
== Upper ==
*5 Real Bout Fatal Fury 2 (7.99)
*6 Guilty Gear X2 /#R (7.89)
*7 Garou Mark of the Wolfes (7.85)
*8 Capcom vs SNK 2 (7.76)
== Mid ==
*9 King of Fighters '98 (7.49)
*10 Samurai Shodown 4 (7.47)
*11 Vampire Savior (7.41)
*12 Last Blade 2 (7.36)
*13 King of Fighters 2k2 (7.28}
== Lower ==
*14 Soul Calibur 2 (6.92)
*15 Project Justice (6.56)
*16 Marvel vs Capcom 2 (6.55)
*17 King of Fighters 2k3 (6.47)
*18 Tekken Tag Tournament (6.05)
== Bottom ==
*19 Samurai Shodown Zero /Special (5.86)
*20 Tekken 4 (5.85)
*21 SNK vs Capcom (5.06)
== Popularity Ranking ==
Gemessen an den abgegebenen Stimmen für das jeweilige Game.
*01 Garou Mark of the Wolfes (40)
*02 Capcom vs SNK 2 (38}
*03 Street Fighter 3rd Strike (36)
*04 Street Fighter Alpha 3 (36)
*5 King of Fighters '98 (35)
*6 Super Street Fighter 2 Turbo (34)
*7 King of Fighters 2k2 (33)
*8 Real Bout Fatal Fury 2 (32)
*9 Last Blade 2 (31)
*10 Virtua Fighter 4 Evolution (29)
*11 Samurai Shodown 4 (29)
*12 SNK vs Capcom (28}
*13 Guilty Gear X2 /#R (27)
*14 Soul Calibur 2 (27)
*15 Marvel vs Capcom 2 (27)
*16 King of Fighters 2k3 (24)
*17 Tekken tag Tournament (24)
*18 Samurai Shodown Zero /Special (22)
*19 Tekken 4 (22)
*20 Project Justice (18}
*21 Vampire Savior (15)
== Rating - Wertebereich ==
Höchste & niedrigste Wertung.
*01 CvS2 : 1.3 - 10.0
*02 GGX2(#R) : 2.0 - 10.0
*03 KoF98 : 4.0 - 9.5 '''(!)'''
*04 KoF2k2 : 3.0 - 9.4
*05 KoF2k3 : 2.0 - 9.2
*06 LB2 : 2.0 - 9.7
*07 MotW : 4.0 - 10.0 '''(!)'''
*08 MvC2 : 2.5 - 8.9
*09 PJ : 2.0 - 9.0
*10 RB2 : 5.0 - 9.5 '''(!)'''
*11 SC2 : 2.0 - 8.8
*12 SF3S : 6.0 - 10.0 '''(!)'''
*13 SFA3 : 5.0 - 10.0 '''(!)'''
*14 SS0 : 3.0 - 8.4
*15 SS4 : 3.0 - 10.0 '''(!)'''
*16 ST : 3.0 - 10.0
*17 SvC : 0.0 - 8.8
*18 T4 : 3.0 - 8.5
*19 TTT : 2.0 - 8.9
*20 VF4E : 2.0 - 10.0
*21 VS : 4.0 - 9.0 '''(!)'''
== Iczer´s Fazit ==
*Third Strike did it !! Mit einer Traumwertung von über 9.0 als einzigstes Spiel, und das bei 36 Stimmen, verdienter Sieger !!
*Evo macht mit gutem Vorsprung den 2. Rang, und scheint dazu das einzigste 3D-Game zu sein was akzeptiert wird (alle anderen haben weniger als 7.0).
*Überrascht hat Real Bout 2 !! Mit 7.99 (!!) um ein Haar das TOP-Ranking verpasst, hat den drittbesten Wertebereich bei 32 Stimmen. RESPEKT !! Keep it goin' RB2-Players ...
*GGX2+ hat sich auch bis zum Schluss durchsetzen können und hat sich konstant unter den ersten 10 gehalten.
*MotW und CvS2, die beiden wohl am meisten umstrittenen Teilnehmer, schließen den UPPER-Bereich würdig ab, MotW sogar als Sieger im Popularity Ranking.
*Überraschung !! KoF98 konnte sich als bestes KoF durchsetzen, und das obwohl es lange hinter 2k2 zurücklag.
*Überraschung Part 2 !! SS4 steht relativ hoch im Kurs auf HE und sichert sich ein Top-10-Rating.
*Vampire Savior, der Underdog, konnte sich zwar nicht bis zum Schluss in den Top 10 halten, schneidet aber solide ab. Scheinbar mag es der Grossteil der es in die Finger kriegt, nur die meisten trauen sich wohl nicht ;]
*Last Blade 2 und KoF2k2 runden die MID's würdig ab.
*zum Rest kann ich nur sagen, 3D is not a HE-thing ^^ "Mutige" Spiele wie PJ oder MvC2 sind nicht wirklich gefragt, HE entschuldigt sich bei Capcom ^^ (ich hoffe ich darf mir das hier mal erlauben, heh). SS0 hat EXTREM schlecht abgeschnitten (im Vergleich zu SS4 auf jeden Fall), und SvC ist wohl wie erwartet Schlusslicht, heh.
*Das wars von meiner Seite, thx für alle die gevotet haben (u gotta bring that line 4 the masses  :D).

Aktuelle Version vom 1. August 2017, 16:12 Uhr

Orginal Thread

Initiator des Votings ist Iczer gewesen. Die Idee dahinter war aktuelle Trends im Forum statistisch abzubilden. Den ersten Vote-Thread findet man hier: Link

Entries

2004 wurden 21 Titel für den Vote ausgewählt. Die Auswahl bestand aus im Tactics Bereich besprochenen Titeln.

VoteNr. Spieltitel Kürzel
1 Capcom vs Snk 2: Mark of the Millennium 2001 CVS2
2 Guilty Gear XX #Reload GGXX#R
3 The King of Fighters '98 KOF98
4 The King of Fighters 2002 KOF2K2
5 The King of Fighters 2003 KOF2K3
6 The Last Blade LB2
7 Garou: Mark of the Wolves MOTW
8 Marvel vs Capcom 2 MVC2
9 Project Justice - Rival Schools 2 PJ
10 Real Bout Fatal Fury 2: The Newcomers RB2
11 Soul Calibur 2 SC2
12 Street Fighter III 3rd Strike: Fight for the Future SF3S
13 Street Fighter Alpha 3 SFA3
14 Samurai Spirits Zero SS0
15 Samurai Spirits 4 SS4
16 Super Street Fighter 2 Turbo ST
17 SNK vs. Capcom: SVC Chaos SVC
18 Tekken 4 T4
19 Tekken Tag Tournament TTT
20 Virtua Fighter 4 Evolution VF4E
21 Vampire Saviour VS

Voting Tabelle

VoteNr. #1 #2 #3 #4 #5 #6 #7 #8 #9 #10 #11 #12 #13 #14 #15 #16 #17 #18 #19 #20 #21 N/A
#1 8.8 7.6 6.8 9.0 8.0 9.0 6.5 7.5 9.0 7.0 N/A 9.2 9.8 8.4 7.0 7.0 6.0 7.0 8.0 8.8 8.4 1
#2 7.5 9.9 5.8 6.2 5.3 7.5 7.8 7.5 4.5 5.0 6.0 9.6 8.2 N/A N/A 8.0 2.0 4.0 5.0 8.5 N/A 3
#3 8.0 9.0 8.5 9.0 8.5 8.0 9.5 N/A N/A 9.0 N/A 9.5 9.0 N/A 8.0 10.0 7.0 N/A N/A N/A N/A 8
#4 7.0 9.2 8.8 9.2 8.0 8.6 9.1 N/A N/A 9.3 N/A 9.6 8.8 N/A 8.4 8.0 6.5 N/A 7.0 9.8 N/A 6
#5 6.0 8.0 8.5 8.5 8.0 8.6 9.5 6.0 N/A 8.7 7.0 9.5 8.0 5.0 8.5 8.0 5.0 N/A N/A 8.0 N/A 4
#6 8.6 9.0 8.5 9.1 8.9 8.7 9.0 8.9 N/A 7.0 8.5 N/A 7.6 7.5 7.3 N/A 8.3 N/A 7.0 7.5 8.0 4
#7 7.5 N/A 7.0 6.5 6.0 6.7 7.9 6.5 N/A 8.0 5.2 8.8 7.0 5.0 6.9 5.5 5.6 5.0 5.1 9.8 N/A 3
#8 5.0 2.0 8.0 7.0 6.0 6.0 9.0 3.0 2.0 7.0 2.0 9.0 6.0 7.0 8.0 3.0 5.0 4.0 7.0 4.0 N/A 1
#9 9.7 6.1 7.9 8.2 N/A N/A 8.4 8.6 N/A N/A N/A N/A 9.2 N/A N/A N/A 8.1 7.7 6.1 N/A N/A 11
#10 8.0 9.0 8.5 8.5 7.0 8.5 8.5 6.0 N/A N/A 8.0 9.5 8.5 N/A N/A 9.0 N/A 5.0 6.0 9.0 N/A 6
#11 6.0 10.0 8.0 9.0 7.0 N/A 7.0 N/A N/A 6.0 N/A 9.0 9.0 8.0 8.0 9.0 5.0 5.0 7.0 10.0 N/A 5
#12 7.0 6.0 5.0 5.0 2.0 7.0 6.0 7.0 7.0 9.0 6.0 10.0 9.0 5.0 6.0 9.0 0.0 7.0 8.0 2.0 8.0 0
#13 8.0 8.5 6.0 7.0 N/A 7.5 7.5 5.0 7.5 7.5 7.0 9.5 8.0 7.0 6.5 8.0 6.0 6.0 N/A 9.5 7.5 2
#14 9.0 9.0 6.0 6.0 3.0 7.0 7.0 8.0 7.0 9.0 5.0 10.0 10.0 5.0 5.0 9.0 -10.0 4.0 5.0 7.0 9.0 0
#15 6.0 9.0 7.0 7.0 N/A N/A 9.0 N/A N/A 7.5 5.0 8.0 8.0 N/A N/A N/A N/A 3.0 N/A 10.0 N/A 10
#16 9.0 7.0 6.0 7.0 5.0 7.0 9.0 5.0 7.0 7.0 8.0 9.0 8.0 6.0 6.0 8.0 4.0 5.0 6.0 10.0 7.0 0
#17 9.5 8.7 7.6 N/A N/A 7.9 8.3 N/A N/A 8.6 N/A 9.1 N/A N/A 8.1 N/A N/A N/A N/A 9.6 N/A 12
#18 9.1 N/A 7.5 7.5 N/A N/A 5.0 8.0 6.5 7.0 8.0 9.0 8.8 7.0 N/A 9.0 0.2 N/A N/A N/A 8.5 7
#19 9.0 N/A N/A 8.7 N/A N/A 8.9 8.8 N/A N/A 8.7 9.7 8.9 N/A 9.0 8.9 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 12
#20 9.0 7.0 N/A 6.0 N/A 8.0 8.0 N/A N/A N/A N/A 8.0 8.0 N/A N/A 7.0 N/A N/A 4.0 9.0 N/A 11
#21 N/A N/A 7.0 9.0 6.5 7.0 10.0 N/A 7.0 N/A 6.0 N/A 8.0 N/A 7.0 7.5 7.0 6.0 7.0 10.0 N/A 7
#22 8.0 N/A 7.5 N/A N/A 7.0 8.5 N/A 8.0 9.5 N/A 9.5 8.0 N/A 7.5 9.0 N/A N/A N/A N/A 7.5 10
#23 5.0 7.0 N/A N/A N/A N/A 5.0 5.5 N/A N/A 4.0 8.6 9.0 N/A N/A 5.0 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 13
#24 7.0 8.6 9.4 8.5 5.5 8.5 10.0 2.5 7.0 8.4 8.0 10.0 6.0 6.0 7.0 8.0 6.0 6.0 4.0 9.0 N/A 1
#25 8.0 N/A 4.0 7.0 5.0 2.0 6.0 N/A N/A 6.0 N/A 10.0 N/A 5.0 3.0 10.0 7.0 N/A N/A N/A N/A 9
#26 1.0 7.4 8.2 8.9 7.9 9.0 10.0 5.0 7.3 9.5 7.0 7.0 5.0 5.0 9.0 7.1 7.4 3.0 2.0 10.0 N/A 1
#27 9.5 7.5 8.5 4.0 7.5 7.0 5.5 8.0 6.0 7.5 8.0 9.0 9.0 3.0 7.5 9.0 3.0 8.0 8.0 9.0 7.5 0
#28 8.9 9.9 6.5 7.0 7.0 N/A 8.0 8.9 N/A 7.5 8.8 9.5 9.0 8.0 8.0 7.5 5.0 7.0 8.9 8.5 6.0 2
#29 6.5 8.5 9.2 8.8 8.5 8.6 9.5 5.5 N/A 9.3 8.0 9.3 9.0 6.0 8.6 8.5 7.0 5.5 5.0 9.8 8.7 1
#30 8.0 N/A 9.0 8.5 N/A N/A 8.5 N/A N/A 8.0 N/A 9.0 9.0 N/A N/A 8.0 8.0 N/A N/A N/A N/A 12
#31 7.0 N/A 4.0 3.0 5.0 6.0 6.0 5.0 N/A 8.0 6.0 9.0 8.0 3.0 7.0 9.0 N/A N/A N/A 9.0 N/A 6
#32 8.6 6.4 9.2 8.5 9.2 9.0 10.0 8.5 7.0 9.5 8.3 9.2 8.7 8.1 9.4 7.1 8.8 8.0 8.4 10.0 7.5
#33 8.5 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 8.0 N/A N/A N/A N/A 9.5 N/A N/A N/A 8.5 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 17
#34 10.0 7.5 7.0 4.0 5.0 5.0 4.0 7.5 5.0 8.0 6.0 6.0 9.5 5.0 5.0 9.0 3.0 6.0 4.0 9.5 6.0
#35 8.0 N/A 9.5 N/A N/A 8.5 10.0 6.0 N/A N/A 7.0 6.0 7.0 N/A N/A N/A 8.0 8.5 8.0 10.0 N/A 9
#36 9.6 8.0 9.4 7.0 N/A 9.7 7.0 7.0 N/A 8.0 8.0 9.9 9.5 N/A 9.0 9.3 N/A 6.0 8.0 9.8 N/A 5
#37 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 7.0 7.0 N/A 7.0 8.0 N/A N/A N/A 4.0 10.0 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 15
#38 5.9 8.4 9.0 N/A N/A 7.9 8.9 6.5 7.9 9.0 7.5 9.1 8.8 N/A 8.6 8.2 N/A N/A 5.8 9.6 N/A 6
#39 8.6 N/A 7.2 8.0 N/A 5.5 7.3 N/A N/A 9.3 N/A 9.5 8.2 N/A N/A 8.0 N/A N/A N/A N/A 7.8 11
#40 9.0 N/A 6.0 4.0 5.0 6.0 5.0 6.0 5.0 6.0 8.0 10.0 6.0 8.0 7.0 10.0 2.0 N/A N/A 5.0 4.0 3

Ergebnisse

Rating Tiers

  • TOP = 8.0 +
  • UPPER = 7.5 - 7.99
  • MID = 7.0 - 7.49
  • LOWER = 6.0 - 6.99
  • BOTTOM = 6.0 -

Top

  1. Street Fighter 3rd Strike (9.04)
  2. Virtua Fighter 4 Evolution (8.86)
  3. Street Fighter Alpha 3 (8.21)
  4. Super Street Fighter 2 Turbo (8.10)

Upper

  • 5 Real Bout Fatal Fury 2 (7.99)
  • 6 Guilty Gear X2 /#R (7.89)
  • 7 Garou Mark of the Wolfes (7.85)
  • 8 Capcom vs SNK 2 (7.76)

Mid

  • 9 King of Fighters '98 (7.49)
  • 10 Samurai Shodown 4 (7.47)
  • 11 Vampire Savior (7.41)
  • 12 Last Blade 2 (7.36)
  • 13 King of Fighters 2k2 (7.28}

Lower

  • 14 Soul Calibur 2 (6.92)
  • 15 Project Justice (6.56)
  • 16 Marvel vs Capcom 2 (6.55)
  • 17 King of Fighters 2k3 (6.47)
  • 18 Tekken Tag Tournament (6.05)

Bottom

  • 19 Samurai Shodown Zero /Special (5.86)
  • 20 Tekken 4 (5.85)
  • 21 SNK vs Capcom (5.06)

Popularity Ranking

Gemessen an den abgegebenen Stimmen für das jeweilige Game.

  • 01 Garou Mark of the Wolfes (40)
  • 02 Capcom vs SNK 2 (38}
  • 03 Street Fighter 3rd Strike (36)
  • 04 Street Fighter Alpha 3 (36)


  • 5 King of Fighters '98 (35)
  • 6 Super Street Fighter 2 Turbo (34)
  • 7 King of Fighters 2k2 (33)
  • 8 Real Bout Fatal Fury 2 (32)
  • 9 Last Blade 2 (31)


  • 10 Virtua Fighter 4 Evolution (29)
  • 11 Samurai Shodown 4 (29)
  • 12 SNK vs Capcom (28}
  • 13 Guilty Gear X2 /#R (27)
  • 14 Soul Calibur 2 (27)
  • 15 Marvel vs Capcom 2 (27)


  • 16 King of Fighters 2k3 (24)
  • 17 Tekken tag Tournament (24)
  • 18 Samurai Shodown Zero /Special (22)
  • 19 Tekken 4 (22)


  • 20 Project Justice (18}
  • 21 Vampire Savior (15)

Rating - Wertebereich

Höchste & niedrigste Wertung.

  • 01 CvS2 : 1.3 - 10.0
  • 02 GGX2(#R) : 2.0 - 10.0
  • 03 KoF98 : 4.0 - 9.5 (!)
  • 04 KoF2k2 : 3.0 - 9.4
  • 05 KoF2k3 : 2.0 - 9.2
  • 06 LB2 : 2.0 - 9.7
  • 07 MotW : 4.0 - 10.0 (!)
  • 08 MvC2 : 2.5 - 8.9
  • 09 PJ : 2.0 - 9.0
  • 10 RB2 : 5.0 - 9.5 (!)
  • 11 SC2 : 2.0 - 8.8
  • 12 SF3S : 6.0 - 10.0 (!)
  • 13 SFA3 : 5.0 - 10.0 (!)
  • 14 SS0 : 3.0 - 8.4
  • 15 SS4 : 3.0 - 10.0 (!)
  • 16 ST : 3.0 - 10.0
  • 17 SvC : 0.0 - 8.8
  • 18 T4 : 3.0 - 8.5
  • 19 TTT : 2.0 - 8.9
  • 20 VF4E : 2.0 - 10.0
  • 21 VS : 4.0 - 9.0 (!)


Iczer´s Fazit

  • Third Strike did it !! Mit einer Traumwertung von über 9.0 als einzigstes Spiel, und das bei 36 Stimmen, verdienter Sieger !!
  • Evo macht mit gutem Vorsprung den 2. Rang, und scheint dazu das einzigste 3D-Game zu sein was akzeptiert wird (alle anderen haben weniger als 7.0).
  • Überrascht hat Real Bout 2 !! Mit 7.99 (!!) um ein Haar das TOP-Ranking verpasst, hat den drittbesten Wertebereich bei 32 Stimmen. RESPEKT !! Keep it goin' RB2-Players ...
  • GGX2+ hat sich auch bis zum Schluss durchsetzen können und hat sich konstant unter den ersten 10 gehalten.
  • MotW und CvS2, die beiden wohl am meisten umstrittenen Teilnehmer, schließen den UPPER-Bereich würdig ab, MotW sogar als Sieger im Popularity Ranking.
  • Überraschung !! KoF98 konnte sich als bestes KoF durchsetzen, und das obwohl es lange hinter 2k2 zurücklag.
  • Überraschung Part 2 !! SS4 steht relativ hoch im Kurs auf HE und sichert sich ein Top-10-Rating.
  • Vampire Savior, der Underdog, konnte sich zwar nicht bis zum Schluss in den Top 10 halten, schneidet aber solide ab. Scheinbar mag es der Grossteil der es in die Finger kriegt, nur die meisten trauen sich wohl nicht ;]
  • Last Blade 2 und KoF2k2 runden die MID's würdig ab.
  • zum Rest kann ich nur sagen, 3D is not a HE-thing ^^ "Mutige" Spiele wie PJ oder MvC2 sind nicht wirklich gefragt, HE entschuldigt sich bei Capcom ^^ (ich hoffe ich darf mir das hier mal erlauben, heh). SS0 hat EXTREM schlecht abgeschnitten (im Vergleich zu SS4 auf jeden Fall), und SvC ist wohl wie erwartet Schlusslicht, heh.
  • Das wars von meiner Seite, thx für alle die gevotet haben (u gotta bring that line 4 the masses :D).
Abgerufen von „https://wiki.hardedge.org/index.php?title=HE_Fighting_Game_Rating_2004&oldid=40788“